The #1 Reason Why The “Stimulus” Package Won’t Work…and 1 Thing That Would Actually Stimulate The Economy

by Andrew

Communication breakdown is what creates most problems…and right now there seems to be a disconnect between Washington, D.C. and the American people.

Government bailouts and "stimulus" packages are confusing not only to the people, but to our Congressmen and women as well.

My goal here is to improve the understanding of how this stimulus package will affect us financially.

The Government’s Financial Statements

Everyone (including the government) has a set of financial statements. These documents help monitor and track where money goes. Most of us don’t think about the government’s too often…and perhaps we ought to.

If you’ve read my others posts, including America’s Financial Future and Is America Bankrupt? you’d see that we are in dire straights financially as a country. It may be helpful to review these posts before continuing to give you a greater context.

Congress has before it a massive "stimulus" package somewhere in the neighborhood of $789 BILLION dollars.

Let’s look at this from a standpoint of simple math and money knowledge…

Assets Liabilities
Taxes Social Security
Medicare
Medicaid
Welfare
Governement Programs
Federal Employees
"Stimulus" Packages

So if we get a "stimulus" package, it becomes a long-term liability on our government’s balance sheet.

The only way for the government to get rid of this long-term liability is by adding assets to the asset column that will generate income to pay for the expense of the liability. It can do this by raising taxes , finding new sources of tax revenue (i.e. tariffs), or by continuing to borrow from overseas. Oh…and it can also print more money. Wouldn’t it be neat if you could do that?

None of these options are pleasant, or will help our nation regain it’s strength.

One reason why this "stimulus" package won’t work: it won’t create enough long-term jobs. There are economists on both sides of the issue, however the simple math doesn’t work.

Our national balance sheet can’t handle another long-term liability that we all will have to pay back with interest…or else print more money and cause inflation.

One way to actually stimulate the economy : reduce the corporate tax rate so companies from other countries would consider moving here and hiring U.S. workers, thus allowing other small businesses to spring up to service these companies and their employees.

According to The Tax Foundation:

"…the average combined federal and state corporate tax rate in the U.S. is 39.3 percent, second among OECD [Organisation for Economic Co-Operative Development] countries to Japan’s combined rate of 39.5 percent"

The table below looks at the relationship between U.S. State and Federal Corporate Tax rates when compared to the rest of the OECD…

Table 1
Comparing U.S. State Corporate Taxes to the OECD

OECD Overall Rank

Country/State

Federal Rate Adjusted

Top State Corporate Tax Rate

Combined Federal and State Rate (Adjusted) (a)

Iowa

35

12

41.6
Pennsylvania

35

9.99

41.5
Minnesota

35

9.8

41.4
Massachusetts

35

9.5

41.2
Alaska

35

9.4

41.1
New Jersey

35

9.36

41.1
Rhode Island

35

9

40.9
West Virginia

35

9

40.9
Maine

35

8.93

40.8
Vermont

35

8.9

40.8
California

35

8.84

40.7
Delaware

35

8.7

40.7
Indiana

35

8.5

40.5
New Hampshire

35

8.5

40.5
Wisconsin

35

7.9

40.1
Nebraska

35

7.81

40.1
Idaho

35

7.6

39.9
New Mexico

35

7.6

39.9
Connecticut

35

7.5

39.9
New York

35

7.5

39.9
Kansas

35

7.35

39.8
Illinois

35

7.3

39.7
Maryland

35

7

39.6
North Dakota

35

7

39.6

1

Japan

30

11.56

39.54
Arizona

35

6.968

39.5
North Carolina

35

6.9

39.5
Montana

35

6.75

39.4
Oregon

35

6.6

39.3

2

United States

35

6.57

39.27
Arkansas

35

6.5

39.2
Tennessee

35

6.5

39.2
*Washington

35

6.4

39.2
Hawaii

35

6.4

39.2

3

Germany

26.38

17.0

38.9
*Michigan

35

6

38.9
Georgia

35

6

38.9
Kentucky

35

6

38.9
Oklahoma

35

6

38.9
Virginia

35

6

38.9
Florida

35

5.5

38.6
Louisiana 35 8 38.5
Missouri 35 6.25 38.4
Ohio

35

5.1

38.3
Mississippi

35

5

38.3
South Carolina

35

5

38.3
Utah

35

5

38.3
Colorado

35

4.63

38.0
Alabama 35 6.5 37.8

4

Canada

22.1

14

36.1
*Texas

35

1.6

36.0
Nevada

35

0

35.0
South Dakota

35

0

35.0
Wyoming

35

0

35.0

5

France

34.43

0

34.4

6

Belgium

33.99

0

33.99

7

Italy

33

0

33

8

New Zealand

33

0

33

9

Spain

32.5

0

32.5

10

Luxembourg

22.88

7.5

30.38

11

Australia

30

0

30

12

United Kingdom

30

0

30

13

Mexico

28

0

28

14

Norway

28

0

28

15

Sweden

28

0

28

16

Korea

25

2.5

27.5

17

Portugal

25

1.5

26.5

18

Finland

26

0

26

19

Netherlands

25.5

0

25.5

20

Austria

25

0

25

21

Denmark

25

0

25

22

Greece

25

0

25

23

Czech Republic

24

0

24

24

Switzerland

8.50

14.64

21.32

25

Hungary

20

0

20

26

Turkey

20

0

20

27

Poland

19

0

19

28

Slovak Republic

19

0

19

29

Iceland

18

0

18

30

Ireland

12.5

0

12.5
*Michigan, Texas and Washington have gross receipts taxes rather than traditional corporate income taxes. For comparison purposes, we converted the gross receipts taxes into an effective CIT rate. See footnote 2 for methodology.
(a) Combined rate adjusted for federal deduction of state taxes paid

Source: OECD, http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/26/56/33717459.xls

As you can see, we are less appealing as a place to help corporations increase their bottom lines. When they go, many jobs go with them (the Multiplier Effect ).

In an age where you can hire an entire staff over the internet for a fraction of the cost of employees in America…it’s time to start rethinking some of our nation’s business policies.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • Tipd
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Mixx
  • Tumblr
  • Technorati

{ 1 comment… read it below or add one }

1 Jonathan Chapman February 15, 2009 at 8:44 pm

Thanks for letting me know about your website. Very informative.

Leave a Comment

Previous post: Why the Global Economy Will Get Worse: The Multiplier Effect…and How It Impacts Your Money

Next post: Time vs. Money